• IE
Choose your location?
  • Global Global
  • Australian flag Australia
  • Canadian flag Canada (FR)
  • French flag France
  • German flag Germany
  • Irish flag Ireland
  • Italian flag Italy
  • Polish flag Poland
  • Qatar flag Qatar
  • Spanish flag Spain
  • UAE flag UAE
  • UK flag UK

Hillsbrough Law: Will the new Duty of Candour change the way we prosecute?

17 November 2026
Hillsbough Law goes far beyond another addition to the compliance landscape. But what does it really mean for regulators and prosecutors?

The Hillsbrough Law, also known as the Public Office (Accountability) Bill is currently passing through the House of Lords and is likely to receive Royal Assent early next year. The new legislation seeks to strengthen duties of candour on public authorities and officials and to address the imbalance that can arise when bereaved families and individuals find themselves confronting well-resourced publice bodies in inquest, inquiries and investigations. In addition, the Bill seeks to introduce a Code of Ethical Conduct which will require public authorities to promote and maintain high standards of ethical behaviour and to adopt, publish and keep under review a code of ethical conduct based upon the Nolan principles – selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership.

The Prosecutor as a public authority

Prosecutors already operate within a framework that demands fairness. Their function is not to secure convictions at all costs and decisions must be taken objectively, disclosure obligations observed transparently and material capable of assisting the defence properly considered fairly.

A statutory duty of candour potentially adds something different.

It asks public authorities to think not merely about whether they have complied with a procedural obligation, but whether they have approached an investigation or prosecution with openness and honesty from the outset.

That distinction could prove important.

Imagine a prosecution. Enforcement officers investigate. Experts are instructed. Internal discussions take place about evidential weaknesses and competing explanations. A prosecution subsequently follows. The conventional question may be: have we complied with our disclosure obligations?

The Hillsbrough Law mindset introduces another approach: have we been completely candid about what we know, including information that is uncomfortable about our own case?

They may sound similar, but they are not necessarily the same.

Defensive decision-making may become increasingly risky

One of the most interesting consequences may therefore be felt before a case ever reaches court.

Public bodies inevitably have reputational interests. It is easy for Investigators and Prosecutors to become intellectually committed to a particular interpretation of events. That is a very human feature of decision-making and does not imply wrongdoing.

A stronger duty of candour should make authorities more alert to this risk.

For bodies exercising both investigative and prosecutorial functions, the implications could be particularly significant. Case strategies, internal governance, disclosure decisions and the recording of reasoning may all require greater scrutiny. The uncomfortable question for an organisation may no longer be simply, "Can we defend this decision?" It may become "Have we openly acknowledged everything that might call this decision into question?"

Disclosure is only part of the story

There is also a danger in treating candour synonymous with disclosure. Disclosure is governed by legal rules. Candour is potentially broader because it concerns institutional behaviour.

The real test may therefore arise when an authority identifies an error in its investigation or disclovers information undermining an earlier position. Does it acknowledge the problem promptly, re-assess its case and explain what has happened? Or does institutional instinct encourage it to maintain the original position until disclosure or judicial scrutiny forces the issue? If Hillsbrough Law succeeds in changing that instinct, its influence could extend well beyond individual prosecutions?

A threat to prosecutors or an opportunity?

It would be easy for prosecuting authorities to regard an enhanced requirement for ethical conduct primarily as another source of risk: more challenges, greater scrutiny and another basis upon which decisions may be questioned. But that would miss the bigger opportunity.

Public confidence in prosecution depends not on authorities appearing infallible, but on them being demonstrably fair. An organisation willing to disclose weaknesses, correct mistakes and revisit decisions may ultimately command greater confidence than one which instinctively defends every step it has taken. The lasting impact of Hillsbrough Law may therefore not be measured by the number of cases brought under it. Its real success in the prosecution world may be judged by something harder to quantify: whether, when the interests of the institution and the pursuit of truth appear to diverge, public authorities instinctively choose the truth.

Is your organisation ready for Hillsbrough Law. Our Regulatory, Investigations and Inquiries team has extensive experience developing organisational resilience before issues arise.

Further Reading