• GL
Choose your location?
  • Global Global
  • Australia
  • France
  • Germany
  • Ireland
  • Italy
  • Poland
  • Qatar
  • Spain
  • UAE
  • UK

R (on the application of Thomas Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire

02 August 2018
Hallway
The recent decision of R (on the application of Thomas Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire changes the standard of proof in Coronial proceedings in determining whether a person committed suicide.

Background

In the early hours of 11 July 2016, the Claimant's brother, James Maughan, was found hanging in his prison cell at HMP Bullingdon. An Inquest into his death was held over four days in October 2017. After hearing the evidence, the Coroner accepted that there was insufficient evidence upon which the jury could rely on to determine that the deceased intended to kill himself. As such, he did not permit the jury to consider a 'short-form' conclusion of suicide. He did, however, invite the jury to record a narrative conclusion based on the balance of probabilities.

The Claim

In a claim for judicial review, the Claimant contended that the jury's conclusion amounted to a 'verdict' of suicide based on the balance of probabilities and was therefore unlawful. It is suggested that the Coroner misled the Jury in inviting them to apply the civil standard of proof (balance of probabilities) when the Coronial guidelines state that a conclusion of suicide, whether given in short form or as part of a narrative statement must only be returned on the criminal standard of proof (beyond reasonable doubt).

The Decision

The reasoning for a higher standard of proof in criminal proceedings is thought to be a result of the severe potential consequences of conviction compared with civil proceedings. However, the Court in dealing with this matter sought to identify civil matters in which the consequences could be said to be just as severe as criminal prosecution and determine whether the simple test of probabilities was still sufficient. Referencing Re H [1996] AC 563 and Re B [2008] UKHL 35; [2009] 1 AC 11, they found that it was.

The Court also found that in civil matters in which it was determined a person had committed suicide the test remained on the balance of probabilities.

The Court, in analysing the position at common law, reiterated the point that suicide is not to be presumed. It stated that mistaken findings of suicide were not overturned because they had not met the criminal standard of proof but because sufficient evidence to justify such a conclusion was not present.

In summary, the Court was satisfied that "the standard of proof required for a conclusion of suicide, whether recorded in short-form or as a narrative statement, is the balance of probabilities" but only when "there is sufficient evidence to justify it".

Read the full judgment here: http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2018/1955.html

Further Reading

We use cookies to give you the best user experience on our website. Please let us know if you accept our use of cookies.

Manage cookies

Your Privacy

When you visit any web site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. We mainly use this information to ensure the site works as you expect it to, and to learn how we can improve the experience in the future. The information does not usually directly identify you, but it can give you a more personalised web experience.
Because we respect your right to privacy, you can choose not to allow some types of cookies. Click on the different category headings to find out more and change permissions. However, blocking some types of cookies may prevent certain site functionality from working as expected

Functional cookies

(Required)

These cookies let you use the website and are required for the website to function as expected.

These cookies are required

Tracking cookies

Anonymous cookies that help us understand the performance of our website and how we can improve the website experience for our users. Some of these may be set by third parties we trust, such as Google Analytics.

They may also be used to personalise your experience on our website by remembering your preferences and settings.

Marketing cookies

These cookies are used to improve and personalise your experience with our brands. We may use these cookies to show adverts for our products, or measure the performance of our adverts.